And the winner is… my dildo! And it fit! I played with my butt plug a bit before I inserted the dildo. It was a struggle but I got it to fit up my tightest hole. I think this vid has a little something for everyone though - enjoy the foot shot and the dripping pussy too!
(And before I get a million asks, yes I put a condom on it. I just prefer to use condoms during ass play in case I want to use the toy (or penis) in my pussy later. And easy cleanup is nice.)